1836 – Chauncey Forward, John Neff
1837 – Andrew Stewart, Michael Shaffer
1838 – Martin Holderbaum, Samuel K. Pearson
1839 – Alexander B. Fleming, Henry Chorpenning
1840 – John C. Kurtz, William Philson
1841 – Jeremiah S. Black, John L. Snyder
1843 – John A. Snyder, Abraham Younkin
1844 – George Mowry, Joseph Cummins, Jacob Cunningham
1845 – Isaac Ankeny, Jonathan Row
1846 – Daniel Flick, John O. Kimmel, John Neff
1847 – Andrew J. Ogle, John C. Kurtz
1848 – John J. Schell, Samuel Huston
1849 – William B. Coffroth, Samuel Kurtz
1850 – Samuel Gaither, Alexander H. Coffroth
1851 – Joseph Herr, Daniel Pile
1852 – Michael A. Sanner, Robert L. Stewart, William J. Baer
1853 – John R. Edie, John D. Roddy
1854 – Aug. Babb, Robert Langhton
1855 – John Meyers, Cyrus Benford
1856 – Ross Forward, Jacob Neff
1857 – Gillian Lint, Curtis Kooser, John J. Schell, Jacob Boblitz, Samuel Gaither, John C. Kurtz
1858 – Ross Forward, Robert P. Cummins
1859 – George B. Fundenburg, Joseph Kerr
1860 – William A. Ogle, Robert R. Marshall
1861 – Ross Forward, John Knable, William H. Koontz, Robert P. Cummins
1862 – Curtis Kooser, David Knable
1863 – William H. Koontz, William B. Coffroth, Elias Cunningham
1864 – Charles A. Kimmel, John J. Schell, John Roberts
1865 – John W. Patton, John J. Schell
1866 – Elias Cunningham, William B. Coffroth
1867 – John H. Weimer, Henry G. Baer
1868 – A. Thomson Ankeny, Alexander H. Coffroth
1869 – Elias Cunningham, Charles A. Kimmel
1870 – Henry F. Schell, Curtis Kooser
1871 – William B. Frease, Isaac Simpson
1872 – Dennis Meyers, Jonas M. Cook
1873 – Ed. Scull, William H. Koontz
1874 – William H. Welfley, Josiah Shaffer
1875 – George M. Neff, J. R. Walter
1876 – William H. Koontz, Ed. Scull
1877 – Josiah Keller, William H. Welfley, Curtis Kooser
1878 – A. J. Colborn, William H. Welfley
1879 – Ed. Scull, Wm. H. Koontz
1880 – George W. Pile, Josiah Keller
1881 – Chas. J. Harrison, Jonas M. Cook
1882 – Ed. Scull, Wm. H. Koontz
1883 – John R. Scott, George W. Pile
(Source: History of Bedford, Somerset & Fulton Counties, PA; 1884)